Skip to content
Party Game Generator

Thanksgiving Would You Rather Questions

Something to fill the gap between the turkey and the pie. All clean, all easy, and most of them are about food, because of course they are.

22 questions ready

Press the button to get your first question.

Tip: press the space bar for the next one.

The full list: 22 questions

Prefer to read them all? Every question in the generator is below.

Thanksgiving (22)

  1. Would you rather eat only turkey or only mashed potatoes on Thanksgiving?
  2. Would you rather have pumpkin pie or apple pie?
  3. Would you rather host Thanksgiving dinner or travel to someone else's?
  4. Would you rather do all the cooking or all the dishes?
  5. Would you rather sit at the kids' table forever or sit next to the loudest relative?
  6. Would you rather watch the parade or the football game?
  7. Would you rather eat Thanksgiving dinner for breakfast or have breakfast for Thanksgiving dinner?
  8. Would you rather have stuffing or mac and cheese as your only side?
  9. Would you rather be a pilgrim on the Mayflower or a turkey on Thanksgiving week?
  10. Would you rather eat cranberry sauce from a can or never have cranberry sauce again?
  11. Would you rather go Black Friday shopping at midnight or stay home in pajamas?
  12. Would you rather have leftovers for a week or no leftovers at all?
  13. Would you rather say what you're thankful for in a song or in a poem?
  14. Would you rather carve the turkey or set the table?
  15. Would you rather have a giant turkey leg or a whole plate of rolls?
  16. Would you rather nap after dinner or play a game after dinner?
  17. Would you rather eat dinner on the floor or eat dinner standing up?
  18. Would you rather have sweet potatoes with marshmallows or without?
  19. Would you rather have Thanksgiving in summer or Christmas in summer?
  20. Would you rather drink apple cider or hot cocoa all day?
  21. Would you rather be in charge of dessert or in charge of drinks?
  22. Would you rather help cook the turkey or help make the pies?

How to play Would You Rather

  1. Get a group together. It works with two people or twenty.
  2. One person reads a question out loud, from the generator or the list.
  3. Everyone picks one option. You have to pick; 'neither' is not allowed.
  4. Each player explains their choice in a sentence. The explanations are the best part.
  5. Pass the phone to the next person and let them draw the next question.

Playing offline? Card games we like

  • Would You Rather? family card game

    Hundreds of printed questions for game nights when everyone should be off their phones.

    See it on Amazon

  • Conversation card decks

    Good for dinner tables and long drives, with questions that go deeper than a party game.

    See it on Amazon

  • Card games for couples

    Date-night decks with romantic and revealing questions, a step up from the couples list here.

    See it on Amazon

These are Amazon links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.

Questions people ask

What is a good would you rather question?

A good one has two options that are close in appeal, so people actually have to think. 'Would you rather have more time or more money?' works because most people want both. If everyone answers the same way, the question is too easy.

Are these questions appropriate for kids?

The 'For kids' category is written for young children and every question in it is clean. The rest of the list is family friendly too, but a few in the Hard and Deep categories touch on topics like death that you may want to skip with little ones.

Can I play Would You Rather over text or on Zoom?

Yes. Draw a question here, press Copy, and paste it into the chat. On a video call, share your screen with this page and let people answer in turn.

How do you win Would You Rather?

Usually nobody wins. If you want a score, have everyone vote and give a point to each player in the majority, or to each player in the minority if you want to reward the odd ones out.

More party game generators